Sometimes multiple threads close the same Socket concurrently. Unfortunately, Android 10 and 11 may crash when this happens: java.lang.NullPointerException: bio == null at com.android.org.conscrypt.NativeCrypto.SSL_pending_written_bytes_in_BIO() at com.android.org.conscrypt.NativeSsl$BioWrapper.getPendingWrittenBytes() at com.android.org.conscrypt.ConscryptEngine.pendingOutboundEncryptedBytes(…
I’m working on Okio’s multiplatform filesystem API. It introduces 3 main types: Path: a value object that identifies a file or directoryFileMetadata: a value object that describes a file or directory, including its type and sizeFilesystem: a service object to read and write files and directories Plus two…
Though Okio has been multiplatform for a year, it still lacks support for reading & writing files. I’ve been thinking about what application developers need and what APIs we should build. But the more I consider it, the more I think, ‘fuck, filesystems are awful’. Files as UIComputing used…
Writing sturdy software is hard work. Sometimes it’s very hard work, but it doesn’t need to be. Very Hard Problem: ORMI have a confession: I like Hibernate. The @Version feature is my favorite; it makes optimistic locking easy and safe. I also like how simple it is to…
Let’s copy a file with bad Java I/O: private void copy(File source, File target) throws IOException { try (InputStream in = new FileInputStream(source); OutputStream out = new FileOutputStream(target)) { while (true) { int b = in.read(); if (b == -1) break; out.write(b); } } } Whoops, it’s super slow. Reading a…
How much time does it take to allocate a byte array? Let’s write a JMH benchmark: @Param({"1000", "10000", "100000"}) int size; @Benchmark public void newByteArray() { byte[] bytes = new byte[size]; bytes[bytes.length - 1] = 'a'; }Running this on my laptop shows that time scales with size: size…
Managing money is work. In addition to the global meltdown that’s going on I must continuously optimize my cost of living, make sure I’m earning enough, avoid taxes, save for retirement, and donate generously. Plus the mild anxiety of whether I should keep HBO and Netflix and Disney+…
I’m often working on some kind of self-improvement: changing my diet, exercising right, or adjusting my work-life balance. But changing my behavior is difficult and I had many failures before any successes. In 2012 I tried to reduce the amount of meat in my diet, from 1-2 times per…
I learned most of what I know about TLS certificates through reading APIs, source code, and specs. My instincts from dealing with ASN.1, X.509, and TLS as a user is that it the APIs are complex, and I should stay away️ from the even more complex implementations. But…
Deploying early & often is addictive. Frequent deploys make it easier to identify regressions, tighten feedback loops, and get fixes to customers sooner. So I’m happy that the Cash App team has tests & tools for frequent deploys. All this deploying has a catch: we don’t notice slow…
I’ve been working on TLS lately. The specs, the APIs, and even the docs make me feel dumb. Why is this so hard?! I struggle when it takes 2 hours to do something that should take 20 minutes. One thing that makes TLS difficult is the jargon and acronyms.…
Being a software developer has changed how I understand lunch. SandwichesOn Saturday I made myself a sandwich, and then my kids wanted one, and then my partner wanted one. For each: Get bread, toppings, knives, plates, cutting boardWash veggies, slice cheese, assemble sandwichDeliver sandwich!Return unused toppingsWash & return dishesMaking…
Certain TLS features like Server Name Indication (SNI) and Application-Layer Protocol Negotiation (ALPN) existed in Android before they had public APIs. The code was there; there just wasn’t a good way to use it. OkHttp hacks around such limitations with reflection. Our internal platform package integrates both Android and…
TLSv1.2 came out in 2008 but Android didn’t get support for it until Android 5 in 2014. Previous releases including Android 4.4 KitKat support up to TLSv1.1 by default. KitKat’s old TLSv1.1 isn’t secure enough and so its retirement has been planned for…
Lots of object models primarily track application state. For example, OkHttp’s Http2Connection.kt has state for whether a ping’s reply is outstanding: private var awaitingPong = false This is set to true each time a ping is sent and then false again when its reply is received. I’ve…
I’m working on some code to sort software versions and it’s tricky. Maven Software that releases to Maven Central should follow Maven’s versioning scheme. This list is sorted by Maven’s scheme: 1.0.0-alpha 1.0.0-beta 1.0.0-rc1 1.0.0-RC2 1.0.0…
I presented this at Droidcon Toronto on November 13, 2019. Available as video, slides, YouTube, & Speaker Deck. Networking on Android is difficult work. We need to display fresh data and rich media while limiting our network use. Unfortunately cookie-cutter solutions are not acceptable. In this talk we’ll: 🥌 Verify…
OkHttp uses synchronized as an allocation free mutex. Our concurrency model is tricky enough that we’ve documented the rules! And if we forget the rules, we also use runtime assertions to catch mistakes: @Override void flush() { // Make sure we don’t hold a lock while doing I/O! assert…
You can do dependency injection (DI) manually or with a library. Constructing your application’s dependency graph by hand is a cute exercise but not practical beyond toy examples. You’ll eventually find yourself extracting the repetitive manual DI code into your own bespoke library, one that’s likely to…
This post expands on a section in my Writing Code That Lasts Forever talk. When I was learning object oriented programming I struggled to define boundaries between classes. Should a Chess game’s Bishop class have a move() method to reposition itself on the board? Should there even be a…
I’m working on OkHttp’s Kotlin upgrade. Java callers use this code to go from a String to an HttpUrl: String string = ... HttpUrl httpUrl = HttpUrl.get(string); Should it remain the same in Kotlin? val string: String = ... val httpUrl: HttpUrl = HttpUrl.get(string) or should we follow the core…
We’re upgrading OkHttp’s implementation language from Java to Kotlin. It’s a big process, especially as we’re maintaining strict compatibility with OkHttp 3.x. Fortunately we’ve done it before and we’re following the strategy Egor & I presented last year. Today we reached a nice…
I presented this at Chicago Roboto on April 26, 2019. Available as code, video, slides, YouTube, & Speaker Deck. Java and Kotlin coders: note this talk. Its tran- script describes some tools to encode any object. I’ll review the libraries including an an- notation that can make your app…
In comparing programming languages I’ve found myself anchoring on what I’m comfortable with and seeing everything else as either “low level and verbose” or “full of syntactic sugar and magical”. I’ve recently gone from using mostly Java to using mostly Kotlin and I’ve learned that syntactic…
Let’s write a small class that has potential to grow. data class ZipCode(val code: String) { init { require(code.matches(Regex("""\d{5}"""))) { "not a zip code: $code" } } } Should you write a unit test for this? Turbo test-driven developers do because…
My recent work requires coordinating teams to build their own pieces of a larger puzzle. We’re going to replace old system 𝒂 with new systems 𝔁, 𝔂, and 𝒛, and that means each team needs to land their contribution on schedule. But in my heart I know that software hates schedules! We’re…
I don’t have a fountain of youth but instead a surprising approximation. You know the expression, “time flies while you’re having fun?” It’s almost right. Your brain’s perception of time flies when you’re doing something familiar. And most importantly, your perception of time slows when…
If you lose 10 pounds, where do those pounds go? It’s weird trivia that I never learned in school. Do you poop it out? pee? sweat? A parallel question clarifies: where does the gasoline goes when you drive your car? The car’s internal combustion engine turns oxygen and…
The IN clause is handy. I use it all of the time. SELECT * FROM cars WHERE make IN ('Ford', 'Subaru') AND price < 5000; +--------+---------+------+--------+-------+ | make | model | year | color | price | +--------+---------+------+--------+-------+ | Ford | Focus | 2007 | Black | 1100 | | Ford | Mustang | 2005 | Yellow | 4000 | | Ford…
We don’t self-identify as software developers but as web developers, backend developers, Android developers, or iOS developers. Many factors reinforce this specialization. I’m a Droid Building systems builds experience. Android developers learn technologies that have no analog on other platforms: activities, intents, and XML layouts. Once we’ve…
I presented this at Droidcon NYC on August 28, 2018. Available as code, video, slides, YouTube, & Speaker Deck. Developers are perpetually fighting yesterday’s code. We need to conquer our immortal fears and build programs that evolve gracefully. In this talk we’ll: 🗿 Discuss code that anticipates the future…
I presented this with Egor Andreevich at Droidcon NYC on August 27, 2018. Available as video, slides, YouTube, & Speaker Deck. Okio is a small library that powers a lot of Square’s open source software, such as OkHttp, Moshi and Wire. Okio makes I/O easy by solving the…
Lots of OkHttp and Retrofit users have reported bugs complaining that URL special characters (like + ; | = * ; ; | or *) weren’t encoded as they expected. Why can’t HttpUrl just encode ; as %3B? Extra escaping is safe in most programming languages and document formats. For example, in HTML there’s no behavior consequence…
I presented this at Chicago Roboto on April 20, 2017. Available as code, video, slides, YouTube, & Speaker Deck. One of Android’s core requirements is that the UI runs on the main thread and IO in the background. Though concurrency is powerful, it’s also frustrating to deal with…
All of OkHttp’s configuration is on the OkHttpClient instance: OkHttpClient client = new OkHttpClient.Builder() .readTimeout(2_000, TimeUnit.MILLISECONDS) .writeTimeout(2_000, TimeUnit.MILLISECONDS) .cache(new Cache(cacheDirectory, cacheSize)) .build(); This design is minimal and simple. There aren’t any precedence rules or hidden settings to be surprised by.…
We publish separate Javadocs for each major release of OkHttp: 1.x, 2.x, 3.x. This is intended to help you out when you’re using an old version. But it’s had an adverse side-effect: Googling for “responsebody okhttp” only returns results for old versions. You see the…
Designing APIs is hard. One technique that helps me is to tell a story with the code: I’ll make a sequence of calls to show how things fit together. I find this helps me to discover what methods I need and what I can leave out. Using features together…
I work on a big Java service that does lots of things. When I snapshot the application’s threads I can see it’s got lots going on: Talking RPC and HTTP Running cron jobs and job queue jobs Persisting to MySQL Coordinating with ZooKeeper Collecting garbage At a glance…
It’s careful work balancing tradeoffs when writing code and designing APIs. Here’s some everyday Java code: for (Protocol protocol : protocols) { if (protocol != Protocol.HTTP_1_0) { result.writeByte(protocol.toString().length()); result.writeUtf8(protocol.toString()); } } On Android—where garbage collector costs aren’t necessarily negligible—I make my…
I’m using an open source library and it crashes in an unexpected way. The crash makes me grumpy because it prevents me from getting my real work done. I don’t want anyone to face this indignity ever again! And so I proceed to report the bug to the…
I presented this at Droidcon NYC on September 30, 2016. Available as code, video, slides, YouTube, & Speaker Deck. Opaque blobs of data have hexed Android programmers for too long. It’s time to byte the bullet and learn how data is transmitted and persisted. In this talk we’ll:…
Karl von Randow has released Charles 4. “With Charles 4 you can now see HTTP 2 working, and you can use all of your familiar tools; Repeat, Breakpoints, and so on. You’ll spot HTTP 2 hosts in Charles as they use a different icon—with a lightning bolt!” I…
One of Java 9’s new features is a replacement for HttpURLConnection. And while I’m thrilled to get rid of that old garbage its replacement has its own surprises. The Good The API is small. The new package is java.net.http and the Javadoc shows only 12 new…
An awkward API OkHttp 1.0 started out as an optimized implementation of HttpURLConnection. This old API is awkward to implement because there is an implicit state machine that corresponds to the underlying network I/O. GET / HTTP/1.1 Host: publicobject.com Accept: text/html HTTP/1.1 200…
We’re in a golden age of reusable open source code. With GitHub and Maven Central it’s never been easier to create and share code. This is excellent! Android developers have access to a steady stream of new projects. I keep up by following some Android developers on Twitter…
Alex Klyubin posted instructions on disabling cleartext networking in Android’s built-in HTTP stack. Ideally, your app should use secure traffic only, such as by using HTTPS instead of HTTP. Such traffic is protected against eavesdropping and tampering. Unfortunately that approach requires Android 6 or better. But if you’re…
Some friends and I do regular boardgame nights. Our favorite is Tichu. The first few times we played we got the rules wrong: we thought certain plays were legal but they weren’t. By playing more, studying the rules, and Googling the edge cases, we eventually got the rules right.…
There’s plenty of good advice on how to do value objects well in Java. Ryan Harter’s AutoValue intro is particularly handy. When I’m not using AutoValue, I like to do my builders as recommended in Item 2 of Effective Java Second Edition. In it Josh Bloch recommends…
Conventional wisdom says that reflection is slow and that it should be avoided. As always, the truth is more nuanced. Let’s start with some code. class Movie { static final List<Movie> BEST_MOVIES = Arrays.asList( new Movie("Back to the Future", 1985), new Movie("…
I’ve been thinking about policies and incentives. A lot of motivation comes down to ceilings and floors. Floors: the worst case. We want to raise the floor, limiting the pain in the worst case. Minimum wage is a floor on labor. Ceilings: the best case. We also want to…